Parks & playgrounds · job 304-15-000370

Improvements and Development of Mesthri Palya Park in Koramangala.

Completed (final bill) Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike · ddo316 Executive Engineer Major Road South Central Zone

₹3.00 Crcontract / award · inferred

₹6.61 Crpaid, gross

9bills

03 Jul 2019last activity

Planned
Contracted
Work documented
Paid
Completed
Physical evidence

no tender found for these bills

This project was reviewed for the investigation cases and set aside: why.

Signals — patterns worth a closer look, not findings of wrongdoing

attention Paid 220% of contract value inferred
Gross payments ₹66,088,036 exceed the contract value ₹30,028,000 by more than GST would explain (work-order values are often quoted excluding 12–18% GST). Variations, work slips, escalation, further work orders under the same job or a longer service period can explain the rest. [source] [source]
notice Blank / placeholder file used as a site photo confirmed
12 photo slot(s) filled with a blank / placeholder file. Bills require before/during/after photos; a placeholder means the photo record for this work is missing. [source] [source]
notice 3 bill(s) registered after the final bill confirmed
Final bill registered 2018-02-23; later non-final bills exist. [source]
notice Identical Completion Certificate attached to another job number confirmed
The same file (md5 632045fbd8…; Completion Certificate) is attached to bills of 2 works: 304-20-000212. Could be one contract booked under two job numbers, or a wrong upload — worth checking. [source]
Related: 304-20-000212
notice Identical Completion Certificate / Job Certificate attached to another job number confirmed
The same file (md5 66a13bffca…; Completion Certificate, Job Certificate) is attached to bills of 3 works: 304-15-000371, 304-20-000212. Could be one contract booked under two job numbers, or a wrong upload — worth checking. [source]
Related: 304-15-000371, 304-20-000212
info Same placeholder file uploaded as evidence on several works confirmed
The same file (md5 af8cd31bb1…; Completion Certificate, Photo - After Work) is attached to bills of 3 works: 304-14-000214, 304-15-000371. A placeholder means the real record is missing. [source]
Related: 304-14-000214, 304-15-000371

1 · What was planned

Work

Improvements and Development of Mesthri Palya Park in Koramangala. confirmed [1]

Where

Unknown unknown

No place name could be read from the description

Estimated cost

Unknown unknown

No estimate published for this work in the sources used

Tender published

Unknown unknown

No tender found or matched for this work

Time allowed

Unknown unknown

No tender document found or matched

2 · Who got the work (contract)

Contractor

B.Y. Perumaiah confirmed [1] [2]

Payee with the largest billed amount under this job number; also billed: B Y PERUMAIAH, M/s Tejus Consultants

Contractor identity

C0034 · B.Y. Perumaiah inferred [1] [2]

Resolved contractor C0034 “B.Y. Perumaiah”; identifiers: no official identifier in the data; name variants joined by: same / truncated name ×2. Also appears as: B Y PERUMAIAH, B Y Perumaiah.

Contract value

₹3.00 Cr inferred [1]

Contract / tender price stated in the Work Order (read by OCR from the scanned document)

3 · Work documented

Bills recorded

4 running, 4 final paid/registered confirmed [1] [2] +2

Bill types recorded in BBMP IFMS for this job's work bills

Work documents

Completion Certificate ×8; Inspection Report ×8; M.B ×12; Quality Certificate ×7; Road History ×8 confirmed [1] [2] +2

Documents attached to the bills in IFMS (their presence is recorded; contents are not verified)

Quantities: planned vs billed

32 planned items read (Schedule B (contract BOQ)); no billed / measured quantity could be read inferred [1] [2] +2

Planned quantities (Schedule B / estimate) against billed (bill abstracts) and measured (typed MB sheets) quantities. Only rows where quantity × rate = amount on the scanned page are used; handwritten MB pages are left unread. Never overrides IFMS amounts.

↳ from a tender matched to these bills (none confidence) — why

4 · Money paid

Paid (gross)

₹6.61 Cr confirmed [1] [2]

Sum of 9 bill(s) under the job number

Paid (nett)

₹2.91 Cr confirmed [1]

Gross minus statutory deductions (tax, security deposit, etc.)

Paid vs contract

220% inferred [1] [2] +1

Gross paid ÷ contract value (contract value is inferred; it may cover only part of the job, e.g. one of several work orders)

Bills

9 confirmed [1] [2]

Unique bills after merging duplicates across exports

First payment

11 May 2017 confirmed [1]

Earliest payment (CBR/RTGS) date

Last payment

03 Jul 2019 confirmed [1]

Latest payment (CBR/RTGS) date

Bill → payment (median days)

14 confirmed [1]

Median days from bill registration to RTGS payment over 8 IFMS bill(s)

Approval remarks

80 remark(s); e.g. 2018-03-20: “Approved by CAO — Approved for payment as per the verification report” confirmed [1]

Remarks written by officials in the IFMS approval chain

11 May 2017cumulative payments03 Jul 2019

5 · Completion

Status

Completed (final bill) inferred [1]

Inferred from the final bill: BBMP raises the final bill when measurement of the completed work is recorded

Work started

Unknown unknown

Actual start date is not published

Expected completion

Unknown unknown

Stipulated period of completion not found in any public record

Final bill

Raised 14 Mar 2019 confirmed [1]

A bill of type “Second and Final” exists

Completed on

Unknown unknown

Final bill does not carry an end date

Completion certificate date

16 Sep 2019 inferred [1]

Completion date stated in the Completion Certificate (read by OCR from the scanned document)

6 · Physical evidence

Site photos

12 site photo(s) attached (before / during / after as labelled); no GPS on any photo checked confirmed [1] [2] +2

Photos attached to the bills in IFMS (type as labelled by the uploader)

Placeholder photos

12 photo slot(s) filled with a blank / placeholder file confirmed [1] [2] +1

Photo attachments whose file name says empty/blank or whose file is a few KB

Quantities: Schedule B vs billed — read from scanned documents; only rows where quantity × rate = amount are used

Item	Unit	Planned	Rate	Billed / measured	Difference	Basis	Confidence	Source
d, tying with binding + Seventy wire and anchoring to the adjoining members Tonne Thousand	tonne	66.53	₹70,000	—	—	not billed / not read	high	[1]
s than Newton per sqmm with cement — mortar : masonry (quoin, Jamb, closer blocks Sqmt Ons	sqm	3,612.48	₹1,100	—	—	not billed / not read	high	[1]
mortar : stone hammerd dressed Thousand in courses not less than ems high, bond Cur Seven	—	992.25	₹3,700	—	—	not billed / not read	medium	[1]
m and fine aggregates AG5Scum - machine mixed, machine mined, concrete laid in Cum Seven ;	cum	655.39	₹4,700	—	—	not billed / not read	high	[1]
Reaffirmed- machine mixed, , © Thousand concrete laid in layers not exceeding cms Cum Five	cum	368.30	₹6,500	—	—	not billed / not read	high	[1]
to the required grade, level Thousand and alignment, rolling with smooth wheeled, Cum Nine	cum	99.20	₹9,900	—	—	not billed / not read	high	[1]
ed, concrete laid in layers not . exceeding cms thick. vibrated for all works in Cum Eight	cum	119.05	₹5,800	—	—	not billed / not read	high	[1]
line and level an jointe . ~ with cement slurry mixed with pigment to match Samt Thousand	—	471.56	₹1,000	—	—	not billed / not read	medium	[1]
erage lift upto .5m, excavated surface levelled and Four Lakh Thirty Cum Four Thousand and	cum	1,736.03	₹250	—	—	not billed / not read	high	[1]
e metal coarse aggregates @ cum and fine : ~ aggregates @ cum, machine mixed, Cum Thousand	cum	79.94	₹5,000	—	—	not billed / not read	high	[1]
ing the surface to remove all - ~ dirt and loose powdered material, free from Samt Seventy	—	5,376.84	₹70	—	—	not billed / not read	medium	[1]
d joined with white cement slurry o over rough plaster surface(excluding cost of Samt ~~ q	—	236.13	₹1,200	—	—	not billed / not read	medium	[1]
and lift upto .5m, Rupees Sixt excavated surface levelled and neatly dressed, Cum "Only "	cum	3,549.46	₹60	—	—	not billed / not read	high	[1]
and removal of ; Rupees Two i form work for foundations, footings, bases of Sqmt Hundred )	sqm	810.34	₹200	—	—	not billed / not read	high	[1]
in layers not exceeding cms. thick, well compacted, in foundation, plinth and cum Thousand	cum	30.84	₹5,000	—	—	not billed / not read	high	[1]
urface including : : Rupees Two rounding off corners wherever required smooth Sqmt Hundred	sqm	624.84	₹200	—	—	not billed / not read	high	[1]
reepers of size y Rupees Four 50x25mm and pointed with Cement mortar of : Sqmt " ° Hundred	sqm	299.80	₹400	—	—	not billed / not read	high	[1]
ar : mix, flush pointing e , Eight a4 with white cement using colour pigment , Smt Hundred	—	94.12	₹800	—	—	not billed / not read	medium	[1]
than 36mmx32mm and also . . Three necessary salwood reinforcements for fixing the Thousand	—	22.05	₹3,400	—	—	not billed / not read	medium	[1]
g, propping etc., for colurnns, Rupees Two pillars, post and struts, square / Samt Hundred	—	273.34	₹250	—	—	not billed / not read	medium	[1]
idth, in hard soil not Rupees Two exceeding m. in depth including dressing the Cum Hundred	cum	290.36	₹220	—	—	not billed / not read	high	[1]
surface including ; Rupees Two rounding off corners wherever required smooth sqmt Hundred	sqm	242.85	₹240	—	—	not billed / not read	high	[1]
usand Six surface such as walls at any thickness, including attached Sqm Hundred and Sixty	sqm	180.59	₹275	—	—	not billed / not read	high	[1]
Six Thousand with synthetic enamel paint in approved shades on new Sqm and Ninty (dot) One	sqm	424.59	₹85	—	—	not billed / not read	high	[1]
rail and styles 100mm ° a Thousand wide as per drawing and panels of 25mm thick sqmt Five	sqm	9.45	₹3,500	—	—	not billed / not read	high	[1]
sand ropping etc., and removal of form work for foundations, g (Pe — Sqm Saver Hundiad era	sqm	111.78	₹275	—	—	not billed / not read	high	[1]
not exceeding ems. in depth, Rupees compacting each deposited layer by ramming Cum Seventy	cum	414.06	₹70	—	—	not billed / not read	high	[1]
and removal of Rupees Two form work for flat surface such as roofs, landings, Sqmt Hundred	sqm	64.24	₹250	—	—	not billed / not read	high	[1]
ith cement mortar : to Hundred ceiling including rounding off corners wherever Sqmt Sevent	sqm	61.32	₹170	—	—	not billed / not read	high	[1]
r thoroughly e Rupees cleaning oil, grease, dirt and foreign matter, sand Sqmt Thirty Only	sqm	23.10	₹30	—	—	not billed / not read	high	[1]
h additional one Rupees Four is coat with lime of approved quality, to give an Samt Only )	—	61.32	₹4	—	—	not billed / not read	medium	[1]
scaffolding wherever necessary, sorting the dismantled Twenty Four ; ; Cum Thousand Three	cum	2.00	₹122	—	—	not billed / not read	medium	[1]

Item

Unit

Planned

Rate

Billed / measured

Difference

Basis

Confidence

Source

d, tying with binding + Seventy wire and anchoring to the adjoining members Tonne Thousand

tonne

66.53

₹70,000

—

not billed / not read

high

[1]

s than Newton per sqmm with cement — mortar : masonry (quoin, Jamb, closer blocks Sqmt Ons

sqm

3,612.48

₹1,100

—

not billed / not read

high

[1]

mortar : stone hammerd dressed Thousand in courses not less than ems high, bond Cur Seven

—

992.25

₹3,700

—

not billed / not read

medium

[1]

m and fine aggregates AG5Scum - machine mixed, machine mined, concrete laid in Cum Seven ;

cum

655.39

₹4,700

—

not billed / not read

high

[1]

Reaffirmed- machine mixed, , © Thousand concrete laid in layers not exceeding cms Cum Five

cum

368.30

₹6,500

—

not billed / not read

high

[1]

to the required grade, level Thousand and alignment, rolling with smooth wheeled, Cum Nine

cum

99.20

₹9,900

—

not billed / not read

high

[1]

ed, concrete laid in layers not . exceeding cms thick. vibrated for all works in Cum Eight

cum

119.05

₹5,800

—

not billed / not read

high

[1]

line and level an jointe . ~ with cement slurry mixed with pigment to match Samt Thousand

—

471.56

₹1,000

—

not billed / not read

medium

[1]

erage lift upto .5m, excavated surface levelled and Four Lakh Thirty Cum Four Thousand and

cum

1,736.03

₹250

—

not billed / not read

high

[1]

e metal coarse aggregates @ cum and fine : ~ aggregates @ cum, machine mixed, Cum Thousand

cum

79.94

₹5,000

—

not billed / not read

high

[1]

ing the surface to remove all - ~ dirt and loose powdered material, free from Samt Seventy

—

5,376.84

₹70

—

not billed / not read

medium

[1]

d joined with white cement slurry o over rough plaster surface(excluding cost of Samt ~~ q

—

236.13

₹1,200

—

not billed / not read

medium

[1]

and lift upto .5m, Rupees Sixt excavated surface levelled and neatly dressed, Cum "Only "

cum

3,549.46

₹60

—

not billed / not read

high

[1]

and removal of ; Rupees Two i form work for foundations, footings, bases of Sqmt Hundred )

sqm

810.34

₹200

—

not billed / not read

high

[1]

in layers not exceeding cms. thick, well compacted, in foundation, plinth and cum Thousand

cum

30.84

₹5,000

—

not billed / not read

high

[1]

urface including : : Rupees Two rounding off corners wherever required smooth Sqmt Hundred

sqm

624.84

₹200

—

not billed / not read

high

[1]

reepers of size y Rupees Four 50x25mm and pointed with Cement mortar of : Sqmt " ° Hundred

sqm

299.80

₹400

—

not billed / not read

high

[1]

ar : mix, flush pointing e , Eight a4 with white cement using colour pigment , Smt Hundred

—

94.12

₹800

—

not billed / not read

medium

[1]

than 36mmx32mm and also . . Three necessary salwood reinforcements for fixing the Thousand

—

22.05

₹3,400

—

not billed / not read

medium

[1]

g, propping etc., for colurnns, Rupees Two pillars, post and struts, square / Samt Hundred

—

273.34

₹250

—

not billed / not read

medium

[1]

idth, in hard soil not Rupees Two exceeding m. in depth including dressing the Cum Hundred

cum

290.36

₹220

—

not billed / not read

high

[1]

surface including ; Rupees Two rounding off corners wherever required smooth sqmt Hundred

sqm

242.85

₹240

—

not billed / not read

high

[1]

usand Six surface such as walls at any thickness, including attached Sqm Hundred and Sixty

sqm

180.59

₹275

—

not billed / not read

high

[1]

Six Thousand with synthetic enamel paint in approved shades on new Sqm and Ninty (dot) One

sqm

424.59

₹85

—

not billed / not read

high

[1]

rail and styles 100mm ° a Thousand wide as per drawing and panels of 25mm thick sqmt Five

sqm

9.45

₹3,500

—

not billed / not read

high

[1]

sand ropping etc., and removal of form work for foundations, g (Pe — Sqm Saver Hundiad era

sqm

111.78

₹275

—

not billed / not read

high

[1]

not exceeding ems. in depth, Rupees compacting each deposited layer by ramming Cum Seventy

cum

414.06

₹70

—

not billed / not read

high

[1]

and removal of Rupees Two form work for flat surface such as roofs, landings, Sqmt Hundred

sqm

64.24

₹250

—

not billed / not read

high

[1]

ith cement mortar : to Hundred ceiling including rounding off corners wherever Sqmt Sevent

sqm

61.32

₹170

—

not billed / not read

high

[1]

r thoroughly e Rupees cleaning oil, grease, dirt and foreign matter, sand Sqmt Thirty Only

sqm

23.10

₹30

—

not billed / not read

high

[1]

h additional one Rupees Four is coat with lime of approved quality, to give an Samt Only )

—

61.32

₹4

—

not billed / not read

medium

[1]

scaffolding wherever necessary, sorting the dismantled Twenty Four ; ; Cum Thousand Three

cum

2.00

₹122

—

not billed / not read

medium

[1]

Running-bill figures show progress at that bill, not final quantities. Comparisons are inferred; see methodology.

Timeline

11 May 2017 Running bill ₹1.43 Cr paid source
03 Sep 2017 Running bill ₹2.20 L paid source
02 Mar 2018 Second and Final bill ₹2.07 Cr paid source
20 Mar 2018 First and Final bill ₹3.33 L paid source
20 Mar 2018 Second and Final bill ₹2.20 L paid source
06 Feb 2019 Running bill ₹2.56 Cr paid source
06 Feb 2019 Running bill ₹3.55 L paid source
20 Mar 2019 Second and Final bill ₹43.66 L paid source
03 Jul 2019 Bill ₹62,700 paid source

How the tender and the bills were connected

Tenders and BBMP bills share no common number, so connections are inferred from independent evidence. Accepted links feed the facts above (marked inferred); possible ones are listed only for review and change nothing.

Possible — not merged · BBMP/2017-18/OW/WORK_INDENT27820 (BBMP tender list 2013–18) · confidence possible · description similarity 76%

“Improvements and Development of Mestripalya Park Balance work at Koramangala, Bangalore” source

✓ same kind of work (park) · same place(s): mestripalya

✗ bills start 224 days before the tender · job-number year far from tender year

Bills & payments (BBMP)

Bill type	Bill reg. (BR)	Work order	Gross	Nett	Payment	Payee	Source
Running	000017 · 27 Apr 2017	—	₹1,42,54,056	—	RTGS 000053 11 May 2017	B.Y. Perumaiah	BBMP work orders under Nagarothana scheme 2016-19 · row 130
Running	000020 · 11 Aug 2017	—	₹2,20,000	—	RTGS 000206 03 Sep 2017	M/s Tejus Consultants	BBMP work orders under Nagarothana scheme 2016-19 · row 250
Second and Final	000037 · 23 Feb 2018	—	₹2,06,94,635	—	RTGS 000405 02 Mar 2018	B.Y. Perumaiah	BBMP work orders under Nagarothana scheme 2016-19 · row 513
First and Final	000038 · 06 Mar 2018	—	₹3,33,000	₹2,99,700	RTGS 000426 20 Mar 2018	M/s Tejus Consultants	BBMP IFMS payment grid (all paid work bills, mid-2015 onward) · row None
Second and Final	000039 · 06 Mar 2018	—	₹2,20,000	—	RTGS 000426 20 Mar 2018	M/s Tejus Consultants	BBMP work orders under Nagarothana scheme 2016-19 · row 536
Running	000015 · 01 Feb 2019	—	₹2,55,82,823	₹2,42,64,311	RTGS 000340 06 Feb 2019	B Y PERUMAIAH	BBMP IFMS payment grid (all paid work bills, mid-2015 onward) · row None
Running	000016 · 04 Feb 2019	—	₹3,55,300	₹3,19,770	RTGS 000340 06 Feb 2019	M/s Tejus Consultants	BBMP IFMS payment grid (all paid work bills, mid-2015 onward) · row None
Second and Final	000021 · 14 Mar 2019	—	₹43,65,522	₹41,17,122	RTGS 000380 20 Mar 2019	B Y PERUMAIAH	BBMP IFMS payment grid (all paid work bills, mid-2015 onward) · row None
—	000007 · 20 Jun 2019	—	₹62,700	₹56,430	RTGS 000104 03 Jul 2019	M/s Tejus Consultants	BBMP IFMS payment grid (all paid work bills, mid-2015 onward) · row None

Bill type

Bill reg. (BR)

Work order

Gross

Nett

Payment

Payee

Source

Running

000017 · 27 Apr 2017

—

₹1,42,54,056

—

RTGS 000053 11 May 2017

B.Y. Perumaiah

BBMP work orders under Nagarothana scheme 2016-19 · row 130

Running

000020 · 11 Aug 2017

—

₹2,20,000

—

RTGS 000206 03 Sep 2017

M/s Tejus Consultants

BBMP work orders under Nagarothana scheme 2016-19 · row 250

Second and Final

000037 · 23 Feb 2018

—

₹2,06,94,635

—

RTGS 000405 02 Mar 2018

B.Y. Perumaiah

BBMP work orders under Nagarothana scheme 2016-19 · row 513

First and Final

000038 · 06 Mar 2018

—

₹3,33,000

₹2,99,700

RTGS 000426 20 Mar 2018

M/s Tejus Consultants

BBMP IFMS payment grid (all paid work bills, mid-2015 onward) · row None

Second and Final

000039 · 06 Mar 2018

—

₹2,20,000

—

RTGS 000426 20 Mar 2018

M/s Tejus Consultants

BBMP work orders under Nagarothana scheme 2016-19 · row 536

Running

000015 · 01 Feb 2019

—

₹2,55,82,823

₹2,42,64,311

RTGS 000340 06 Feb 2019

B Y PERUMAIAH

BBMP IFMS payment grid (all paid work bills, mid-2015 onward) · row None

Running

000016 · 04 Feb 2019

—

₹3,55,300

₹3,19,770

RTGS 000340 06 Feb 2019

M/s Tejus Consultants

BBMP IFMS payment grid (all paid work bills, mid-2015 onward) · row None

Second and Final

000021 · 14 Mar 2019

—

₹43,65,522

₹41,17,122

RTGS 000380 20 Mar 2019

B Y PERUMAIAH

BBMP IFMS payment grid (all paid work bills, mid-2015 onward) · row None

—

000007 · 20 Jun 2019

—

₹62,700

₹56,430

RTGS 000104 03 Jul 2019

M/s Tejus Consultants

BBMP IFMS payment grid (all paid work bills, mid-2015 onward) · row None

Original system: BBMP Works Bill Public View / IFMS (account.bbmpgov.in). Linked files are public exports of that data on OpenCity.

Why this is a Koramangala project

Work description names Koramangala: "…Improvements of Mesthri Palya Park at Koramangala.…"